Picture two kickers at the same summer camp. Same warm-up, same field, same snapper rotation. One charts 6-of-10 from 45 with a long of 52. The other goes 8-of-10 from 45 with a long of 51. Guess which one gets a note written next to his name. It is almost never the one with the highlight-reel bomb. Consistent windows beat lucky longs, and that idea should shape every number you chase this year.
Below are the benchmarks that matter, what they roughly look like at each level, and — more important — how to get real numbers of your own instead of practicing blind.
Why Numbers Come Before Names
A college staff can only care about kickers they have already noticed, and numbers are how you get noticed from far away. A coach scanning a list of 200 kickers does not watch your tape first. He sorts by the numbers in your subject line: field goal range, kickoff distance, hang time. The numbers are the filter. The film is what closes him after the filter lets you through.
So the goal is not one sexy number. It is a clean, boring, repeatable set of them — numbers that hold up on a Tuesday practice chart the same way they did on your best day.
The Numbers Coaches Actually Chart
Every program tracks a slightly different board, but these show up everywhere:
- Consistent FG range: the distance where you make 8 of 10 on demand, not your career long. Coaches care about the floor, not the ceiling.
- Made percentage at each hash and from each distance band, ideally across the season rather than one great session.
- Kickoff distance and hang time: distance alone is only half the story. A 60-yarder with a 3.4-second hang gets returned. A 58-yarder at 4.3 gets covered.
- Operation timing: snap-to-kick. College and pro staffs want the whole operation fast and smooth, and they will notice if you are slow through your steps.
- Left-foot ability on kickoffs or punting ability: if you can give a staff two jobs, your value doubles.
Ballpark Benchmarks by Level
Take these as rough orientation, not gospel. Every staff builds its board differently, weather, altitude, and ball type shift everything, and a camp chart on neutral ground carries more weight than a home-practice claim. But if you want to know whether your season chart is in the conversation, this is the honest neighborhood:
| Level | Consistent FG range | Kickoff | What gets noticed |
|---|---|---|---|
| High school varsity | 35-40 yards, clean contact | 55-60+ yards, 3.5-4.0s hang | Consistency and operation speed over raw distance |
| D3 / NAIA | 40-45 yards | 58-63 yards, ~4.0s hang | Reliability, academics, multiple-sport value |
| D2 | 43-48 yards | 60-65 yards, 4.0s+ hang | Averaging kickoffs into the end zone |
| D1 FCS | 45-50 yards | 62-68 yards, 4.0-4.3s hang | Charted consistency from both hashes |
| D1 FBS | 50+ yards with margin | 65+ yards, 4.2s+ hang | All of it, plus poise on film in real games |
If you are below the line for the level you want, that is not a verdict — it is a to-do list. Numbers move fastest for kickers who fix contact and swing path before they chase strength. A kicker who goes from 48 to 55 usually did it with better contact, not bigger legs.
Get Your Real Numbers: A Charting Protocol
Most kickers overestimate their range because they remember their best ten kicks and forget the other forty. Fix that with a simple protocol, run twice a month:
- Pick a day with average conditions and note the wind in your log.
- From each hash, hit a set of 10 kicks at a distance you should own (start at 35 for most high schoolers).
- Move back 5 yards and do it again until you miss more than half. Your consistent window ends where your percentage drops under 80.
- For kickoffs, average 6 kicks: distance and hang time, both counted, both recorded.
- Log it all: date, field, wind, hashes, makes/attempts, long. Trends matter more than single days.
Now you have something a coach can trust, because you can produce it on demand. “I make about 80 percent from 43 on any given Tuesday” is a recruiting sentence. “My longest was 57 once” is not.
What to Do When a Number Comes Up Short
Every kicker has a number that embarrasses him on his own chart. Do not hide it — train it, in the right order. If your consistent range is 38 and you want 45, the fix order matters: contact quality first (the cheapest yards in kicking), then swing speed, then strength. A kicker who fixes contact usually gains three to five yards without feeling any more powerful, because the energy was leaking sideways the whole time. If your hang time is the weak spot, that is a contact point problem more often than a leg speed problem — a strike slightly low on the ball climbs higher and lands softer.
Then update your numbers honestly as they move. Coaches do not expect a junior to have senior numbers; they expect to see a trend line. “Made 62 percent from 40 last season, 78 percent through five games this year” is the sentence that gets a slow-starting kicker on a list. The short number only disqualifies you if you stop moving it.
Numbers Open the Email. Film Closes It.
A great stat line gets your email opened. A clean, tight tape with operation speed, hashes, and weather kicks is what turns the open into a reply — which is why charting and film work belong in the same week of your life. If you are not sure where your numbers stack up against the level you are chasing, that is a solvable problem: get them charted properly, get them on film, and get them in front of coaches.
If you want a second set of eyes on your kicks and a plan to move those numbers, that is exactly what I do through remote film review coaching — you send the film and your chart, I send back the contact and swing fixes that actually move distance. And if you want to see how your range compares level by level, read the field goal distance chart by level next.
Two more reads that pair with this: the college coach email templates that get your chart opened, and the recruiting tips that explain what coaches actually look for in a specialist.
